Skip to main content
Opinion

Could a two-tier system save Test cricket from itself?

MACHEL HEWITT: The adage goes that West Indies won’t get better without playing the best teams, but the stats show that after twenty-five years of playing the best teams, they have not got better. If anything, it has been a steady decline. 

17.10.25, 17:44 Updated 17.10.25, 17:44

Avatar of Machel Hewitt
by Machel HewittEditor

Since the year 2000, West Indies have played 88 Test series and won just 21 of them, a win percentage of 24%. Dive deeper into the stats and you’ll find that only 7 of those 21 wins were against teams that weren’t called Afghanistan, Zimbabwe, or Bangladesh. To put it another way, West Indies have not won a Test series against Australia or South Africa in the 21st century. Let that sink in.

Of their 67 series losses, 23 were whitewashes, and more damningly, if you look at Test matches away from the Caribbean, West Indies have only won 19 of the 122 they’ve played.

I could go on, but the point should already be clear. 

In any other team sport, if those stats were presented to you, you would assume you were looking at a lower-division side or a team in absolute freefall and heading for relegation. But this team is playing in the top tier and is in no danger of relegation. Nor will they face any consequences for a quarter of a century of substandard performance.

Become a member today.

Caribbean Cricket News needs its community to support independent, high-quality coverage of West Indies Cricket. Subscribe to a monthly or annual package today to be a part of something special.

Subscribe now

Already have an account?

More like this